Workshops and Projects » Mobility in Nairobi 2009 » Non-motorized vehicles: small-scale mobility soultions

 

Info

Year
2009
Place
Nairobi, Kenya
Participants
André Sheydin
Menza Amani Katana
Dancan Omondi Odhiambo

Initial Position

In today's world we are surrounded by transportation modes, which transport us or objects of any kind from place to place. These engines have been playing an important role in their development because they save enormous human and animal muscle effort. But in certain contexts, non-motorized vehicles (non-motorized vehicles, NMVs) are more advantageous. For cost and efficiency reasons, entire populations have long reach back to this means of transport available which independence of operating costs and the absence of waste gases evolved over time to an ever-increasing benefit. In Kenya, introduced in 2000, the non-motorized transport, including walking consisted of more than 45 percent of transportation in urban centers. 

In Nairobi, many people cannot afford an own car, so they resort to non-motorized vehicles, which require neither fuel nor complex maintenance. Due to the high volume of Mkokoteni (big Handcart) in Nairobi, these vehicles get into dangerous situations that are increased of a number of factors. 

Firstly there is the almost exclusive focus of traffic facilities on motorized vehicles, on the other there are huge vulnerabilities of non-motorized vehicles, especially when they operate in these areas. NMVs are threatened by the growing number of motorized vehicles, the loss of space on the street in relation to the dangers of the growing population density and changes in the urban area. The needs of NMVs are overshadowed by motorized vehicles in the road building. 

The trend in transport with NMVs is declining. In the next decade, the NMV transport could fall even further due to these circumstances. In the informal economy, especially in slums, NMVs are an indispensable in means of affordability and essentially enabling existence.

Perspective: improvement suggestion example

The observations and interviews with students and traffic participants in Nairobi have shown that drivers of Mkokoteni are confronted with enormous risks. Some of these risks can be traced back to resolvable problems in automotive engineering. The design goal in this context is two-fold: first, the reduction of injuries caused by accidents that the drivers of this type of vehicle are exposed to, and second, the disturbance of other traffic participants should be lowered by increasing the controllability of the vehicle type.

The disadvantages of this type of vehicle can be neutralised by technological transformation and adaption of available solutions. At this point it is conceiveable to get in touch with german patent-holders in order to implement and transfer this know-how to Nairobi. Another possibility would be to reuse component parts from the automotive industry, as this technology is already accessible and available on wasteyards etc. Imaginable improvements can be prioritized in the following order:

  • Effectivity of the brakes through alternative braking systems.
  • Driver’s seat with impact protection.
  • Configuration with acoustical and visual signalling devices.
  • Trailing possibility by adaptive trailer coupling devices.
  • Use and stroage of driving power in order to decrease manual expenditure of energy in a dynamo-like manner.
  • Controlling grips.

Any vehicular modifications must be reviewed and secure against vandalism and theft. This poses an important challenge since the installations must also have a minimal resale value.

Bibliography

Item Overview

#67 Big Boda bicycle frame extension

The Big Boda (designed by WorldBike) is a steel frame extension that attaches to any bicycle making even the flimsiest frame into a durable and hefty transportation option which is able to carry hundreds of poinds of cargo or two additional passengers. It was designer as a cheap solution to transport goods to and from market for entrepreneurs and consumers in developing countries. more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#68 Wheelchairs participate in traffic

The physically handcapped are allowed by the city council to sell anything in some parts of the city centre. Physically capable persons are not allowed to hawk in the centre. Many people don't go to markets at night due to security issues and the distance. Some hawkers pretend to be physically handcapped as they rent those wheelchairs from particular places to do business illegaly. The primary business of... more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#69 Mkokoteni escaping traffic congestion

A mkokoteni driver with his vehicle is trying to pass a car congestion. As he finds himself in dead end, he uses the wending capability of his two wheeled vehicles and turns over using very little space. This manouver makes it possible for him to move further and to search another route while the motorized vehicles have to wait until the traffic jam dissolves.

We see maybe the main advantage of two wheeled... more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#70 Typical mkokoteni construction

A close-up of a typical mkokoteni made of metal and wood. The operator extended the space between him and the metal with a rope web probably to avoid injuring impacts while on high speed.

  more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#72 Bicycle at the Globe Cinema Roundabout

A bicycle driver transporting water on the Globe Cinema Roundabout. He has to mix up with motorized vehicles beacause there are no separated lanes which brings him in dangerous situations. more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#73 Parked trolleys

Trolleys of a similar manufacture type stored without security near the business district. Each of them carries a rope to fasten loads and a phone number for renting the cart itself or to hire a person who would transport goods. They are used to transport goods between shops and/or markets.

  more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#74 Handcart used as a chair

During dwelling the cart serves the non-intentional function of a chair. Probably the situation symbolizes a free-to-hire transportation service near to loading zones. more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#75 Mkokoteni as number one transportation tool between markets

A mkokoteni operator mit his vehicle on a typical market road where motorized vehicles are unthinkable. The mkokoteni is empty and the operator is in quick motion probably on the way to load the vehicle. On his way through crowded areas he gives signals with his mouth (which are very individual) for the people to go aside because people would not hear the non-motorized vehicle approaching.

  more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#76 Mixed traveling modes on the Globe Cinema Roundabout

The leading mkokoteni with a heavy load on it is beeing pulled by a person on the rear while beeing directed by the person at the front. Another well loaded mkokoteni is following while a jeep is trying to get between them maybe to turn left and to leave the roundabout. The second mkokoteni tries to slow down to create a gap for the turning in car. The cars are beeing decelerated by the relatively slow... more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#77 Market port

Entrance area of a market where many mkokoteni are beeing observed transporting goods in and out which is an important issue to the informal economy. Also many people transport sacks on their back or their head.

  more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#78 Parked mkokoteni

A parked mkokoteni in a residential-area. Parking of mkokotenis require much less space than a car because amongst its size the vehicles can be stapled into each other.

  more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#79 Trolley participating in road traffic

Trolleys are also traffic participants on highly motorized roads since there are no separate lanes for non-motorized transport.

  more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#80 Transportation bicycle

One of the rare bicycles in Nairobi that were explicitly made for transportation. The load in front can be observed by the driver while driving.

  more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#81 Heavily loaded mkokoteni

A heavily loaded mkokoteni pulled by one man. The load consists of very different elements which allow the conclusion of a private transportation probably with a hired operator.  more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#82 Peak hour

The situation shows the typically slow movement of motorized vehicles during peek hours. It happens that the pedestrian travel mode is much more effective in large areas of the city.

  more

27 Sep 2009 by André Sheydin

#88 Traffic congestion

Traffic congestion during peak hours.

  more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#90 Animal transport

Animal powered carts are mostly pulled by donkeys in common means on the outskirts of the city. The loading capacity is larger than human-powered NMVs. more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#91 Mkokoteni mdogo

Mkokoteni mdogo, a small handcart (dolly) has a shorter axle width then the mkokoteni and enables navigation through traffic jams. It is suited for one person and can be used in areas with high pedestrian density. more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#93 Loaded mkokotenis

Transportation of goods from larger warehouses to smaller warehouses at the Kirinyaga Road. more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#94 Bicycle carrier

Bicycles are mostly used for personal transport, but can also be used for transporting goods loads from 100 to 180 kg. In Nairobi, bicycles are a major means of transporting charcoal to restaurants in the town. The material is usually sourced from the outlying suburbs of Nairobi.

  more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#96 Boda boda waiting for passengers

The boda boda, bicycle for passengers, is a cheap alternative to taxis that can quickly move through traffic jams. The capacity is limited to one passenger and one driver. more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#97 Water transportation uphill

With the current water rationing the hand-pulled carts are instrumental in the supply of water to some homes and restaurants.

  more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#98 Mkokoteni stappled together

Mkokoteni stapled together at a market entrace. more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#99 Transportation service hotline

Transportation service hotline. more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#100 Transportation Mode change at Wakulima Market

Transportation mode change at Wakulima Market. more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#101 Locked trolley

Locked trolley. more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#102 Road partitioning

Common road partitioning in Nairobi. The street divides the rich (left) and the poor (right). more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#103 Difficult topography for bicycles

Bicycles are most efficient over distances from around 600 to 800 m and up to 5 to 7 km.

  more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

#105 Self-organising system

Still, even the lack of planning and predictability in terms of infrastructure produces its own qualities, since it spawns self-organising systems that flexibly adapt to the prevailing conditions, instead of slavishly following rigid rules. The transport connections arise through flexible, self-determined agreements of an autogenous self-organised system.

  more

06 Feb 2010 by André Sheydin

Interview with a mkokoteni operator

Njuguna James Kariuku is a 23 year old mkokoteni operator and broker who earns his living money with mkokotenis.

more

on 01 Jan 1970 with Njuguna James Kariuki by André Sheydin